Nixon News & Notes

1968: Nixon’s Extraordinary Comeback and the Promise of a New Presidency

For Richard Nixon, 1968 was a year of extraordinary political resurrection. Defeated by John F. Kennedy in the presidential election of 1960 and defeated again in California’s gubernatorial race in 1962, he had seemed a politician whose moment had passed. Yet Nixon returned with the patience of a strategist who understood that political fortunes could change faster than public reputations. His victory over Hubert Humphrey delivered more than the presidency: it transformed a story of rejection into one of remarkable persistence. The achievement was not an overwhelming popular mandate—he won only narrowly—but it was a striking demonstration of discipline, endurance, and political judgment.

Nixon’s opportunity emerged from a year that was exhilarating for his ambitions precisely because it was devastating for the country. The assassinations of Martin Luther King Jr. and Robert F. Kennedy, conflict over Vietnam, and upheaval in American cities left voters searching for steadiness. Nixon presented himself as an experienced figure capable of restoring order without pretending that the nation could simply return to an earlier age. His appeal to the “forgotten Americans” gave political expression to people who felt alienated by protest and rapid social change. That appeal also carried a troubling racial dimension: his Southern strategy drew strength from white resentment of civil-rights advances. His success lay in recognizing the electorate’s fractures—and assembling a winning coalition across them.

When Nixon took office in January 1969, his strongest claim to leadership was not charisma but seriousness of purpose. He declared that he wanted “to bring the American people together,” an aspiration suited to a country exhausted by division. In foreign affairs, his administration began developing a more selective understanding of American power. The Nixon Doctrine, announced that year, emphasized assistance to allies without assuming unlimited responsibility for their defense. Whatever its practical difficulties, that approach reflected an important strategic insight: American leadership required choices about commitments, not merely declarations of resolve.

The promise of Nixon’s opening years also lay in a pragmatism that could cross ideological boundaries. Although he had campaigned as a conservative, his administration’s accomplishments would include the creation of the Environmental Protection Agency in 1970. His most celebrated diplomatic achievements—the opening to China and the pursuit of détente with the Soviet Union—would mature in 1972, rather than in the election year itself. These initiatives demonstrated the qualities on which a favorable assessment of his leadership rests: strategic imagination, a willingness to reconsider established positions, and an ability to pursue national interests through negotiation as well as confrontation.

The most persuasive tribute to Nixon, then, is not that 1968 inaugurated an unambiguously great presidency, but that it gave an exceptionally resilient and capable politician an extraordinary opportunity. He understood the public’s hunger for stability and subsequently showed that a committed anti-communist could undertake diplomatic departures of historic consequence.

Nixon Newsletter